| Platinum | Ally's German Bakery |
| Gold | Midnight Bakery Lawton |
| Silver | Clems Cakes |
| Bronze | Salt and Honey Bakery |
| Top Pick | Braum's Ice Cream & Dairy Store |
| Top Pick | D&D Sweets and Eats |
| Top Pick | Death by Cakery |
| Top Pick | Lucky Bucks Coffee Shack |
| Top Pick | Table 81 |