| Platinum | Firo Fire Kissed Pizza |
| Gold | Ben & Jays Pizzaria |
| Silver | Papa Louie's Pizzeria |
| Bronze | Pizza Hut |
| Top Pick | Chuck E. Cheese |
| Top Pick | Luigi's Express Gyros & Pizza |
| Top Pick | Made in New York Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Mama Donatos |
| Top Pick | Pizza Corral |
| Top Pick | Rising Eagle Brewery |