| Platinum | Midnight Bakery Lawton |
| Gold | Death by Cakery |
| Silver | Ally's German Bakery |
| Bronze | Nothing Bundt Cakes |
| Top Pick | J Donut |
| Top Pick | Little Crown Bakery |
| Top Pick | Mrs. Chadwick's Bakery |
| Top Pick | Ms. Pam's Sweet Dragonfly |
| Top Pick | Stephanie's Cookie Barn |
| Top Pick | Table 81 |